Management ER: Can this employee be saved?
Thursday, February 28th, 2008Years ago, I remember a column in a prominent women’s magazine, maybe Good Housekeeping, entitled “Can this marriage be saved?” The story would be told from his point of view and hers, followed by analysis and counsel. A bit sappy perhaps, but many people read it avidly. I lost interest by the time I hit high school, but the title has stayed with me.
Recently, I heard from a client that he had fired a high level, long-term employee. For some reason, the old column title popped into my brain. I think it’s germain. Let me tell you why.
When an employee’s performance slips, what should be the employer’s first thought? Get rid of him/her? Too often, that is the knee-jerk reaction of an inexperienced manager. Of course, there are times when promptly “making the employee available to industry” is absolutely the right course of action. But not always. Not even most of the time.
So what’s an employer to do? Take a step back and ask yourself a critical question first. Can this employee be saved?
Finding and hiring good people is an expensive proposition. The expense goes up with the level of employee you are trying to hire. Add to that the cost of training an employee over time and the value of the institutional knowledge and experience he/she develops during the years spent with your company, and losing someone packs a financial wallop. So, be aware of the costs and be sure you can’t avoid the loss by addressing issues with the employee.
Consider the following:
- Does the employee have a performance plan? A clear understanding of the work expected of him/her?
- Have you articulated your expectations clearly to your employee? It is a constant surprise to me how frequently this isn’t done. Employees are not mind-readers.
- Have you discussed your concerns about the employee’s performance privately with the employee, openly and honestly? No one likes confrontation, but if you don’t clearly articulate your concerns and give the employee a chance to respond, you are doing the employee and your company a serious disservice. (By the way, don’t forget to document these critical conversations!)
- Did you provide all the tools and training necessary for the employee to accomplish the task?
- If the employee responds to your direction and counseling, will you and the rest of your team be able to continue working effectively with him/her? The relationships can sometimes be strained beyond repair.
Ensuring that your employees have clear direction, defined jobs and tasks, and a full understanding of your expectations will go a long way to making your job as a manager easier and your company more successful. Employees are your most expensive and valuable asset. Make sure you take appropriate management action before resorting to firing one of them.