Bailouts - good or bad for the economy?
Friday, March 28th, 2008Everyone seems to be in an uproar over the economy. It has reached the point where some concern is certainly warranted. The pressure is on our government to take immediate steps. But is this the right approach? Should our government dive in with big bailouts and big government programs? Running up more national debt is not going to help our economy. It will hurt in any number of ways, including further weakening of the dollar.
Over lunch today, I listened to reports and discussions addressing this subject. Most of it was focused specifically on the mortgage “crisis”. There is much wailing and gnashing of teeth over the poor homeowners who can’t manage their increased mortgage payments and may be faced with losing their homes. Although I feel real compassion for anyone in danger of losing his/her home, I think the current discussion is taking place without adquate context. That context is this. Only a very small percentage (around 2% is the number I heard on the news today) of homeowners find themselves in this bind. The other 98% are meeting their obligations, in spite of adjustable rate mortgages adjusting upwards. So the crisis is really overblown, at least when considering people losing homes. You’d hardly know this, to listen to the average newscaster, not to mention the politicians.
So is it right for that responsible 98% to bear the cost for the 2% who overextended themselves? Because that’s who will bear the cost if the government starts buying mortgages or bailing out homeowners - we, the taxpayers. I don’t think so.
Should we find ways to offer information, guidance and other support to help struggling homeowners wend their way through the mortgage morass? Sure! I’m all for education, coaching, and guidance. That’s a far better way to deal with the current crisis. It’s cheaper and more effective in the long run, since a better educated consumer will be more responsible with their choices in future. Perhaps we can prevent a repeat.
Lest you think me hardhearted or lacking in compassion, let me assure you that I don’t think we should be bailing out corporations, either. I would much rather see our free market and strong capitalism function without government interference. It works better that way, ensuring a strong economy for all of us!